This is for the course “Critical Academic Writing” taught, in English, at the University of Warsaw’s Faculty of Psychology.
This course is designed to teach first-year MA students in psychology the skills necessary for academic writing in English in order to write a quantitative, high-quality MA thesis.
A high-quality MA thesis presents an argument based on facts and logic and thus has a clear contribution to the discipline and field of study.
The course will highlight important stages of the journey from research idea to MA thesis:
- Structure and critique
- Building productive writing habits
- Organizing your research
- Hallmarks of good writing
- Specific applications, namely, titles and abstracts, introduction, and theory and hypotheses
Students will learn how to efficiently and effectively collect, interpret, criticize, and synthesize information from multiple sources.
Class 1. Introduction to Academic Writing
A. Understanding the audiences and purposes of academic writing; Contributions, i.e. answering, “so what?”
Required: “Leadership Lab: The Craft of Writing Effectively,” by Larry McEnerney, Director of the University of Chicago’s Writing Program
B. Structure of empirical research articles in psychology
Required: Appelbaum, M., Cooper, H., Kline, R. B., Mayo-Wilson, E., Nezu, A. M., & Rao, S. M. (2018). Journal article reporting standards for quantitative research in psychology: The APA Publications and Communications Board task force report. American Psychologist, 73(1), 3.
Optional: A Brief Guide to Writing the Psychology Paper
Lecture Notes
Contributions: “How to write the introduction.”
What is an empirical research article in the social sciences?
Philosophy of Writing: How to think about academic writing in the social sciences
Concepts are the building blocks of research articles
The American Psychological Association provides specific guidelines as to the structure of empirical research articles in psychology, including for qualitative research:
Levitt, H. M., Bamberg, M., Creswell, J. W., Frost, D. M., Josselson, R., & Suárez-Orozco, C. (2018). Journal article reporting standards for qualitative primary, qualitative meta-analytic, and mixed methods research in psychology: The APA Publications and Communications Board task force report. American Psychologist, 73(1), 26.
UC San Diego Psychology also has a good webpage on the structure of psychology articles.
Class 2. Writing Habits, Productivity, and Using AI Assistants
A. Using AI assistants and digital tools to improve your writing
Required
Google NotebookLM https://notebooklm.google/
ASReview Lab https://asreview.readthedocs.io/en/latest/index.html
Taylor & Francis AI Policy https://taylorandfrancis.com/our-policies/ai-policy
Elsevier Generative AI policies for journals https://www.elsevier.com/about/policies-and-standards/generative-ai-policies-for-journals
Optional: Our Kids’ IQs are Dropping
Optional: “OpenAI CEO Sam Altman | AI for the Next Era” (2022)
Optional: Miao and Holmes. 2023. Guidance for generative AI in education and research – Unesco
B. Writing habits and productivity
Required: Smith, Chris. 2018. “Six academic writing habits that will boost productivity.” LSE Impact Blog
Optional: Peterson, Todd C., Sofie R. Kleppner, and Crystal M. Botham. 2018. “Ten simple rules for scientists: Improving your writing productivity” Plos
DUE: Notes on “Leadership Lab: The Craft of Writing Effectively” (ca. 200 words)
Lecture Notes
- Artificial Intelligence (AI) and the Social Scientist
- How to use ChatGPT in Social Science Research
- Quantitative Research in the Social Sciences and ChatGPT
- ChatGPT Deep Research Output Misleads Us about Data Collection and Analysis
AI Assistants
- ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini
- Otter.ai for real-time transcriptions
- Notebook LM for synthesizing knowledge materials
- Notion AI a “second brain” to streamline your notes
- Google Scholar Labs and Elicit.org and Consensus.app and Connected Papers for finding research articles
Lecture notes for Writing Habits and Writing Strategies
Class 3. Finding, Reading, and Organizing Academic Research
Required
- Carson et al (2012) Writing for Psychology: A Guide for Psychology Concentrators. Read chapters “How to Read Sources Critically”, “Writing a Conceptually Coherent Paper,” and “Academic Honesty in Writing”
Optional: A Brief Guide to Writing the Psychology Paper
Lecture notes
How to Find, Read, and Organize Academic Social Science Research
DUE: AI-assisted concept list, thesis statement, and title (ca. 200 words)
Class 4. Knowledge gaps and phrasing the research question
Lecture Notes
- Concepts are the building blocks of research articles
- Knowledge gap and examples
- Research Questions with Examples
DUE: Literature review, min. 5 academic sources (500 words, plus references)
Class 5. Thesis Statement and on Writing Well
A. Crafting a thesis statement
Required: Thesis Statements from UNC Chapel Hill (nb: it is broad and designed mainly for essays and not specifically for empirical research articles, but their advice applies to what you are doing fairly well)
B. Writing clear and well-developed paragraphs; Arcs: Connecting point-first paragraphs
Required: Carson et al (2012) Chapter “Do’s and Don’ts of Effective Writing in Psychology”
Carson et al (2012) Chapter “Do’s and Don’ts of Effective Writing in Psychology”
Lecture notes
Arcs and Flow: Good academic writing with examples
DUE: Knowledge gap statement: “whereas we know this, we do not know that…” (100 words)
Class 6. From Introduction to Critical Literature Review
A. How to write the introduction
B. From critical literature review to theory and hypotheses
Lecture Notes
How to Write the Introduction to a Research Article in the Social Sciences
How to write the theory section of a research article in the social sciences
DUE: Critical analysis of an article: Students will write a critical analysis of an article published in a psychology journal (300 words)
Class 7. Titles and Abstracts
Lecture notes
Effective titles in social science research are short, truthful, and informative
How to write an abstract for a social science research article
DUE: An introduction to your research (300 words)
FINAL RESEARCH REPORT DUE ONE WEEK AFTER THE LAST CLASS
